Five different stories intersect on Halloween evening combining in a terrifying lesson that some traditions are best not forgotten. A couple learn that you never blow out a jack-o-lantern before midnight, a group of teens play an evil trick on another unsuspecting teen that goes too far, a high school principal reveals his strange appetite, a group of college girls including a virgin look for the perfect man for her first time and a lonely old man is visited by a very interesting trick 'r treater.
